Historical Context of Invasions and generational trauma
- Türán
- May 23
- 5 min read
Updated: Jun 1
A Profound Exploration of Inherited Fear Among Pashtuns: Generational Trauma and the Gandharan Disconnect
Historical Context of Invasions
Pashtuns, living in regions like Afghanistan and Pakistan, have faced invasions for centuries, including by Alexander the Great, the Arabs, Mongols, and British. These events, marked by violence and displacement, likely contributed to a collective trauma passed down through generations, affecting mental health and cultural identity.
Intergenerational Trauma Among Pashtuns
Studies show high rates of PTSD and depression among Pashtun refugees, with 45% experiencing lifetime depression and a third meeting criteria for major depression or PTSD. This suggests invasions and conflicts have left a legacy of fear and psychological distress, impacting family and community dynamics.
Connection to Gandhara
Gandhara, an ancient kingdom in Pashtun lands, was a Buddhist center, but with Islam's rise, Pashtuns' identity shifted. Some Pashtuns see Gandhara as part of their heritage, while others feel disconnected, fearing it conflicts with their current religious identity.
Fear of Gandharan Roots
Pashtuns may fear their Gandharan roots due to religious tensions with Buddhism, historical trauma from invasions that erased pre-Islamic culture, and a lack of knowledge about this past, compounded by political and social pressures to prioritize Islamic identity.
A Profound Exploration of Inherited Fear Among Pashtuns: Generational Trauma and the Gandharan Disconnect
The Pashtun people, residing primarily in southern and eastern Afghanistan and northwestern Pakistan, have long been defined by their resilience and warrior spirit, rooted in a history of resistance against invaders. However, beneath this exterior lies a complex legacy of inherited fear, a form of intergenerational trauma passed down through centuries of relentless invasions. This article delves into how these historical traumas have shaped Pashtun identity, exploring the psychological and cultural impacts, and examines why many Pashtuns may harbor a fear or reluctance to connect with their ancient Gandharan roots, a heritage rich in pre-Islamic Buddhist culture. The connection to Pashto music, a vital expression of Pashtun identity, will also be woven into this narrative, highlighting continuity and disconnection.
Historical Context of Invasions
The Pashtun regions, often referred to as Pashtunistan, have been a geopolitical crossroads, witnessing invasions since the 2nd millennium BCE. Excavations suggest early human presence, with subsequent waves including Ancient Iranian peoples, Greeks under Alexander the Great, Indians, Kushans, Hephthalites, Arabs, Turks, Mongols, and later the British and Soviets. This history of conflict has ingrained a culture of vigilance, but also a deep-seated fear and trauma.
Intergenerational Trauma: Mechanisms and Manifestations
Intergenerational trauma, or the transmission of trauma across generations, is well-documented in conflict zones, particularly affecting mental health. For Pashtuns, decades of war, from the Soviet invasion to recent Taliban conflicts, have left lasting scars. A 2018 EU survey found 85% of Afghans witnessed at least one traumatic event, with 50% suffering psychological distress. This trauma manifests as emotional numbness, anxiety, and disrupted family dynamics, passed through parenting behaviors and epigenetic changes, as seen in Holocaust survivors’ descendants.
Pashtun Experiences of Trauma
Pashtuns, as the largest ethnic group in Afghanistan (48%) and significant in Pakistan (15-18%), have borne the brunt of these conflicts. The Taliban’s rise and US-led invasions post-2001 have intensified this, with civilian casualties and displacement reinforcing a cycle of fear. Pashtunwali, their code of honor, demands defending land, but this resistance often comes at the cost of further trauma, embedding fear in collective memory.
The Gandharan Connection
Gandhara, flourishing from the 1st millennium BCE to the 2nd millennium CE, was a Buddhist center in what is now Pashtun lands, known for Greco-Buddhist art and trade.
Pashto Music: A Bridge and a Barrier
Pashto music, with instruments like the Rubab (possibly linked to Gandharan lutes), reflects continuity with ancient traditions . Genres like Tappa and Charbetta, accompanied by poetic lyrics, express Pashtun identity, often tied to resistance and daily life. Yet, this music, while preserving some Gandharan rhythms, also embodies the trauma of invasions, with songs of valor and loss echoing historical fears, creating a bridge to the past but also a barrier, as modern Pashtun identity prioritizes Islamic narratives over pre-Islamic ones.
Fear of Gandharan Roots: Religious Identity Conflict
Many Pashtuns may fear their Gandharan roots due to religious identity conflicts. Gandhara’s Buddhist past, with monks and stupas, contrasts with their current Islamic identity, potentially seen as heretical or irrelevant. This fear is evident in mixed opinions on Reddit, where some Pashtuns see Gandhara as their ancient past, while others, like Effective_Ad_7170, claim it belongs to Hindkowans, highlighting a disconnect.
Historical Trauma and Cultural Suppression
The history of invasions that destroyed Gandharan culture, from Huns to Arabs, has left a legacy of trauma, making it painful to confront. Assad Sharifi’s reflection on discovering Gandhara as a lost Pashtun heritage, feeling “silenced, stolen, buried,” suggests a collective amnesia, with generations replacing this past with submission and violence. Educational narratives often prioritize Islamic history, suppressing pre-Islamic roots, fostering fear of reclaiming them.
Political and Social Implications
Claiming Gandharan roots can have political implications, especially in Pakistan and Afghanistan, where ethnic identities are contested. Some Pashtuns may fear that acknowledging a non-Islamic past could be used to undermine their current identity or territorial claims, as seen in debates over Pashtunistan and regional politics. This fear is compounded by social pressures to conform to Islamic norms, distancing from Buddhist heritage.
Psychological Barriers and Lack of Knowledge
Many Pashtuns lack knowledge of Gandhara due to historical erasure and limited education on pre-Islamic history. This ignorance breeds fear, as the unknown past feels alien or threatening. Sharifi’s call to “remember Gandhara to rediscover who we are” highlights this barrier, urging Pashtuns to ask, “Who were we, really?”
Efforts to Reconnect and Heal
Despite fears, movements like NeoGandhara seek to reclaim Gandharan heritage, seeing it as a path to healing intergenerational trauma. By embracing their ancient roots, Pashtuns can foster pride and continuity, using Pashto music and art to bridge past and present. Efforts in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa to document oral histories and train youth in traditional instruments like the Rubab reflect this resolve .
Conclusion
The Pashtun people’s legacy of inherited fear, rooted in centuries of invasions, has shaped a complex relationship with their Gandharan heritage. Intergenerational trauma, manifested in high PTSD and depression rates, reflects the psychological toll of historical violence. Fear of Gandharan roots stems from religious conflicts, historical trauma, cultural suppression, and political pressures, yet reconnecting offers a path to healing. By embracing their past, Pashtuns can rediscover their identity, using Pashto music as a bridge to a richer, unbroken heritage, echoing the rhythms of Darwishan’s hills.
Comentários